Underoath brings controlled chaos to 191 Toole in Tucson

Underoath’s “Van Tour to Vans Warped Tour” has quickly become one of the most sought-after tickets of the summer. The concept is simple: before embarking on their biggest headlining tour to date later this year, the band is revisiting the kind of intimate club shows that helped build their career more than two decades ago — something they had talked about doing for years and finally made a reality.

When the tour was announced, Underoath promised it would be sweaty, loud, and sold out, and they delivered on that promise.

On Thursday, July 23, fans packed into a very sold-out 191 Toole in Tucson, AZ, to experience the kind of set they never thought they’d get to see from Underoath again. Making the trip from Phoenix should have been an easy two-hour drive, but an accident on the only route into Tucson turned it into a four-hour trek. As frustrating as that was, it became obvious almost immediately after arriving that it was well worth the drive. This was the kind of show people will be talking about for years to come.


Opening the night was New York newcomers Held., who are currently out on their very first tour as a band. You never would have guessed it. The post hardcore trio looked completely at home on stage, delivering a confident nine-song set filled with energy. Floral arrangements decorated the microphone stands and drum kit, adding an unexpected visual contrast to the band’s aggressive sound. Their regular drummer was away touring with Coheed and Cambria, but their fill-in never missed a beat, fitting seamlessly into the performance. Frontman Douglas Robinson shared with the crowd that he had been battling an illness, something that you never would have noticed. His vocals remained powerful throughout the set, while bassist Sal Mignano played through what appeared to be a heavily bandaged and battered hand that never seemed to slow him down. Opening with “DEFENDING THE EARTH,” Held. quickly had the crowd nodding along before launching into tracks like “WAVES OF FIRE,” “THROUGH THE CRACKS,” and “GREY.” By the time they closed with “NEW YOU ANTHEM,” the room was fully warmed up and ready for what was to come.

FOLLOW HELD. | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM | YOUTUBE | SPOTIFY


I had made it to the venue just in time to secure a spot front and center, and while I had some reservations about whether it was a good idea to plant myself in the center of it all, the energetic but respectful crowd had me convinced I might actually survive the night without incident. As it turns out, fans were simply conserving every ounce of energy they had for Underoath.

Within seconds of Underoath taking the stage, the room erupted into complete chaos. Bodies surged toward the stage from every direction, crowd surfers appeared almost immediately, and stage divers launched themselves into the sea of people without hesitation. Somewhere during the opening moments of “Breathing in a New Mentality,” I was kicked square in the face by a stage diver before two separate crowd surfers landed directly on top of me. Sandwiched between a few hundred sweat-soaked bodies and Spencer Chamberlain’s shins, I found myself questioning every life decision that led me to that exact spot. It was at that moment that this elder emo realized she could no longer hang with the rest of ‘em and it was time to see herself out of the pit.

Despite the absolute madness unfolding around me, it was impossible not to appreciate what was happening. This was exactly the experience longtime Underoath fans had been craving. There were no barricades separating the band from the audience, and there was no over the top production — just a packed room filled with people who had waited years for the opportunity to experience Underoath this way again.

The intensity never let up. Fans continuously climbed onto the stage to snap selfies, record quick videos, and throw themselves back into the crowd. Spencer Chamberlain eventually joined them, diving headfirst into the audience himself as hundreds of voices screamed every lyric back at the band. The 13-track setlist mixed Underoath classics like “It’s Dangerous Business Walking Out Your Front Door” and “Reinventing Your Exit” with newer material like “All the Love Is Gone” and “Damn Excuses.”

As the temperature inside the venue climbed, Chamberlain joked that Tucson was on pace to become the sweatiest stop of the tour. Looking around the room, it was hard to argue. Every person inside 191 Toole looked absolutely drenched, but nobody showed any interest in slowing down. The nonstop rotation of crowd surfers and stage divers continued from the first song until the very last.

Late in the set, Chamberlain noted that keyboardist Chris Dudley was always happy about something —something that becomes immediately apparent when watching him perform. It’s impossible to watch him absolutely let loose on the keys with a giant smile on his face without sharing in his joy. The crowd immediately began chanting his name, which Chamberlain jokingly interpreted as sounding like they were chanting, “Drink! Drink!” A shot then appeared onstage, and the audience went wild, chanting for Dudley to take it and erupting into cheers when he did.

Aaron Gillespie once again proved why he is one of the most impressive musicians in heavy music. Somehow balancing flawless clean vocals while delivering an absolutely relentless performance behind the drum kit, he made one of the most physically demanding jobs on stage look effortless. Few musicians can do what he does, and even fewer can make it look that easy. As usual, his performance was nothing short of incredible.

As the night neared its conclusion, Chamberlain told the crowd they would play one new song and one old one. Before launching into “Generation No Surrender,” he taught everyone the song’s defining chant, instructing fans to scream “GENERATION NO SURRENDER” whether they knew the song or not. Within moments, the entire venue was shouting the words back in unison, making the new track feel like a longtime fan favorite.

Without an encore, the band closed out the night with “A Boy Brushed Red Living in Black and White,” and despite how exhausted the crowd of mostly elder emos must have been, the chaos only intensified. Bodies were flying in all directions and the stage was packed with fans as they sang along with everything they had left. It was the perfect ending to a performance that never once lost its intensity.

Big arena productions have their place, but they can’t replicate the feeling of seeing a band like Underoath in a room this small. There was no distance between the band and the audience — just a packed club full of people feeding off each other’s energy. If the “Van Tour to Vans Warped Tour” was meant to bring fans back to those early club shows, it did exactly that. It may have left everyone soaked in sweat, covered in bruises, and no doubt in need of a hefty dose of ibuprofen, but judging by the smiles on faces walking out of 191 Toole, nobody would have wanted it any other way.

The “Van Tour to Vans Warped Tour” wraps on August 2. While the remaining dates are sold out, if you’re lucky enough to get your hands on a pair of tickets, it’s a show you won’t want to miss, and an experience fans are not likely to have again any time soon. Later this year, Underoath is set to embark on their largest headlining tour to date, celebrating the 20 year anniversary of Define the Great Line. Tickets are on sale now and can be purchased here.

Follow UNDEROATH | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM | FACEBOOK | YOUTUBE | SPOTIFY

Leave a Reply